Ethereum is back at 2023 prices: what 5 years of $10 a day in ETH returned

Ether is trading around $1,820 (live: $1,756.69) — the same level as its monthly close in March 2023 and about 63% below its all-time high of $4,946 from August 24, 2025. For people who buy a little every day, that means something rare: five years of $10 a day in ETH is worth $14,642 on $18,260 invested (−19.8%), while the same habit in Bitcoin, the S&P 500 and gold is in profit.
Below: why ether is falling now, how this drop compares with its earlier crashes, and what the numbers say about buying regularly through a long sideways market.
Key takeaways
- Ether is about 63% below its August 2025 record; US spot ether ETFs lost about $399 million in net outflows from November 9 to 13.
- Over five years, $10 a day in ETH is at −19.8%, versus +43.3% for Bitcoin, +43.7% for the S&P 500 and +46.7% for gold.
- The average 5-year buyer paid roughly $2,200 per ETH, so ether would need a rise of about 20% — not 170% — for them to break even.
Why ether is falling this month
- ETF money is leaving. US spot ether funds recorded about $398.9 million of net withdrawals in the November 9–13 trading week, according to Farside Investors data cited by crypto.news and Coinpaper. The biggest single day was $184.6 million.
- A sharp weekend drop. Ether fell more than 8% on November 14 and briefly hit about $1,712 on Sunday, November 15, before bouncing back above $1,800. It is down roughly 14% in a week.
- Rate-hike fears. Traders on Kalshi put the chance of a quarter-point Federal Reserve hike in December at about 89%. Higher rates make assets that pay no fixed income, like most crypto, less attractive.
- Mood at rock bottom. The Crypto Fear & Greed Index read 12 out of 100 ("extreme fear") on November 17, down from 53 a month earlier.
Not everyone is leaving: about 36.5% of circulating ETH is staked — locked up by holders to earn network rewards — according to a validator report cited by Coinpaper. Live headlines are on our news page.
Ether has crashed harder than this before
On monthly closing prices from our data, ether has had three deep falls:
- 2018–2019: from the January 2018 peak to January 2019 — −90%. It took three years to reach a new monthly high (January 2021).
- 2021–2022: from November 2021 to December 2022 — −74%.
- 2025–2026, so far: from the August 2025 monthly close — about −59%.
So today's fall is not the worst in ether's history, which also means it could go deeper. Past recoveries are history, not a promise. Our all-time-high tracker shows how far every major coin is from its peak.
What steady ETH buyers have now
Five years ago, in November 2021, ether was at its highest monthly close ever: about $4,630. Buying then was close to the worst possible timing.
- $1,000 put in at once five years ago is worth $379.27 today (−62.1%).
- $10 every day for the same five years: $18,260 invested, now worth $14,642 (−19.8%).
Both are in the red, but the daily buyer lost far less, because they kept buying cheap coins in 2022 and 2023. That pulled their average price down to roughly $2,200 per ETH (as of November 16). The lump-sum buyer, by contrast, paid about $4,630 and needs ether to more than double just to break even.
Here is the sentence worth remembering: in a five-year sideways market, regular buying did not make money in ether — it only made the loss smaller.
Time in the market still mattered a lot. Someone who started $10 a day eight years ago, in late 2018 near the bottom of the first crash, is at +193% ($85,702 on $29,220 invested). And someone who started just one year ago is at −18.8%, because most of their buying happened near the 2025 top.
The same five years of $10 a day across four assets:
| Asset | Invested | DCA · 5 years | Result | $1,000 5 years ago |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ethereum | $18,260 | $14,642 | −19.8% | $379.27 |
| Bitcoin | $18,260 | $26,166 | +43.3% | $1,086 |
| S&P 500 ETF | $18,260 | $26,246 | +43.7% | $1,680 |
| Gold | $18,260 | $26,784 | +46.7% | $2,018 |
What it means if you buy regularly
Ether's last five years show both sides of DCA honestly:
- DCA spreads timing risk; it does not remove price risk. If an asset goes nowhere for years, a regular buyer goes nowhere too — or lower.
- The breakeven is closer than the headline. A 63% fall from the top sounds hopeless, but a regular buyer's average cost is far below the peak. Whether ether gets back there is unknown.
- One coin is a concentrated bet. Over the same period the S&P 500 and gold rose steadily while ether swung wildly. Mixing assets changes the ride; try it in the comparison tool.
- Size the habit so you can keep it. Only money you won't need for years belongs in crypto. Our habits calculator shows what a small daily amount adds up to, and the compound interest calculator shows the slower, steadier path.
If you do buy, use a large, regulated platform — our exchange comparison lists fees and features.
Sources
- crypto.news — Ethereum price falls 14% as four-year support comes into focus
- Coinpaper — ETH drops 64% from record high as $1,700 becomes critical
- CoinGabbar — Crypto news Nov 17: Fear index, Fed rate hike odds
- Prices, all-time highs and DCA results: WhatIfStack data (Yahoo Finance, CoinGecko, Binance); Fear & Greed: alternative.me.
Not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
👀 Track it on WhatIfStack
Add these assets to your free watchlist or portfolio — live prices, profit and news in one place, no sign-up.
Once a week: what happened to crypto, stocks and gold, the best and worst assets, and our top articles. No spam.
Only the weekly report. Unsubscribe in one click from any e-mail.